2024 9(1)

JUNE 2024

Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs) in Islamic Perspective: Challenges and Way Forward

Azlin Alisa Ahmad​​, azlinalisa@ukm.edu.my
Research Centre for Sharia, Faculty of Islamic Studies, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia
Received: April 29, 2024 | Revised: June 14, 2024 | Accepted: June 21, 2024 | Published: June 30, 2024

2024, Vol. 9(1), pp. 8-15.  |  PDF

Non-fungible tokens (NFTs) have recently emerged as a novel application of blockchain technology in digital asset transactions. However, the integration of NFTs into Islamic finance remains limited due to several unresolved Shariah issues. This qualitative study employs content analysis to review past studies on NFTs from a Shariah perspective. The primary focus areas include the compliance of NFT transactions with the pillars of sale (bay’), the classification of NFTs as wealth (mal) in Islamic law, the use of cryptocurrency in NFT transactions, and the copyright protection of NFTs as digital assets. The key challenges identified encompass the lack of clear Shariah parameters governing NFT mechanisms, differences in scholarly opinions, the prevalence of ambiguity and uncertainty in NFT valuation and ownership, the high carbon footprint associated with NFT platforms, and inadequate legal protection for users. To facilitate greater adoption of NFTs in Islamic finance, this paper recommends the formulation of comprehensive Shariah parameters and guidelines, enhancement of transparency in royalty distribution, utilization of energy-efficient platforms, and the establishment of appropriate governance frameworks. Mainstreaming a Shariah-compliant NFT ecosystem has the potential to drive innovation in Islamic fintech and the broader digital economy.

KEYWORDS
​Non-fungible token; Islamic finance; Shariah compliance; fintech  

Ahmad Raihan. 2023. Perlindungan hak cipta atas Non-Fungible Token (NFT) sebagai aset digital di Indonesia. Tesis Sarjana, Program Studi Hukum Ekonomi Syariah, Universitas Islam Negeri Maulana Malik Ibrahim Malang. 

Aji Teguh Prihatno, Naufal Suryanto, Sangbong Oh, Thi-Thu-Huong Le & Howon Kim. 2023. NFT image plagiarism check using EfficientNet-Based Deep Neural Network with Triplet Semi-Hard Loss. Applied Sciences 13(3072): 1-20. 

Alex Zarifis & Luis A. Castro. 2022. The NFT purchasing process and the challenges to trust at each stage. Sustainability 14(16482): 1-13.  

Ammar Battah, Mohammad Madine, Ibrar Yaqoob, Khaled Salah, Haya R. Hasan & Raja Jayaraman. 2022. Blockchain and NFTs for trusted ownership, trading, and access to AI models. IEEE Access 10: 112230-112249.  

Anatoli Colicev. 2023. How can Non-Fungible Tokens bring value to brands? International Journal of Research in Marketing 40: 30–37.  

Anon. 2019. Non-Fungible Tokens: 101 Guide. Slaid. 

Ante, L. 2022. The Non-Fungible Token (NFT) market and its relationship with bitcoin and ethereum. FinTech 1: 216-224.   

Ardanu Bagas Wicaksono.  2021.  Bagaimana NFT dan Smart Contract dapat mempengaruhi kewangan Syariah. Alami Institute, 27 Disember. https:// alami.institute/learn/nft-smart-contract-syariah [20 Julai 2023]. 

Azrul Azlan Iskandar Mirza. 2023. Isu-isu Syariah: Smart Contract, DeFI, Metaverse & NFT. Slaid. Muzakarah Cendekiawan Syariah Nusantara ke-17. 

Chandra, Y. 2022. Non-Fungible Token-enabled entrepreneurship: a conceptual framework. Journal of Business Venturing Insights 18 (e00323): 1-9. 

Chen, Z & Omote, K. 2022. Toward achieving anonymous NFT trading. IEEE Access 10: 130166-130176.  

Christian Pinto-Gutiérrez, Sandra Gaitán, Diego Jaramillo & Simón Velasquez. 2022. The NFT hype: what draws attention to Non-Fungible Tokens? Mathematics 10(335): 1-13. 

Dinar Standard. 2021. Global Islamic Fintech Report: 1-56.  

Dominic Chalmers, Christian Fisch, Russell Matthews, William Quinn & Jan Recker. 2022. Beyond the bubble: Will NFTs and digital proof of ownership empower creative industry entrepreneurs? Journal of Business Venturing Insights 17 (e00309): 1-8.  

Dong, YP & Wang, CH. 2023. Copyright protection on NFT digital works in the Metaverse. Security and Safety 2: 2023013, pp. 1-14.  https://doi.org/10.1051/sands/ 

Dowling, M. 2022a. Fertile LAND: Pricing Non-Fungible Tokens. Finance Research Letters 44 (102096): 1-5. 

Dowling, M. 2022b. Is Non-Fungible Token pricing driven by cryptocurrencies? Finance Research Letters 44 (102097): 1-6.  

Faraz Adam.  2021.  NFTs: shariah compliant?  Amanah Advisors, 4 Mac. https:// amanahadvisors.com/nfts-shariah-compliant/ [5 Julai 2023]. 

Florian Idelberger & Péter Mezei. 2022. Non-fungible Tokens. Internet Policy Review 11(2): 1-9.  

Foteini Valeonti, Antonis Bikakis, Melissa Terras, Chris Speed, Andrew Hudson-Smith & Konstantinos Chalkias. 2021. Crypto collectibles, museum funding and OpenGLAM: challenges, opportunities and the potential of Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs). Applied Sciences 11(9931): 1-19.  

Frankenfield, J. 2022. October 27. Non-Fungible Token (NFT). Investopedia, 27 October. https://www.investopedia.com/non-fungible-tokens-nft-5115211. 

Gustira Hidayatul Iman. 2022. Transaksi jual beli Non-Fungible Token (NFT) perspektif hukum ekonomi syariah. Tesis Sarjana, Program Studi Hukum Ekonomi Syariah, Universitas Islam Negeri Mataram. 

Hilal Azmi. 2022. Meneroka pasaran AS$1 trilion dalam dunia baharu digital. Astro Awani, 15 Mei. https://www.astroawani.com/berita-malaysia/meneroka-pasaran-1-trilion-dalam-dunia-baharu-digital-361450 [20 Julai 2023].  

Hisny Fajrussalam et al. 2022. Pandangan Islam terhadap NFT di era digital. As-Sabiqun: Jurrnal Pendidikan Islam Anak Usia Dini 4(1): 151-162.  

Hong Bao & David Roubaud. 2021. Recent development in Fintech: Non-Fungible Token. FinTech 1: 44–46.  

Igor Bonifacic. 2022. Over 80 percent of NFTs minted for free on OpenSea are fake, plagiarized, or spam. Engadget, 29 Jan. https://www.engadget.com/opensea-free-minting-tool-220008042.html?_fsig=v8QHd2_W_XYBhoFZFEolHA–%7EA [28 Julai 2023].  

Jon Truby, Rafael Dean Brown, Andrew Dahdal & Imad Ibrahim. 2022. Blockchain, climate damage, and death: Policy interventions to reduce the carbon emissions, mortality, and net-zero implications of Non-Fungible Tokens and Bitcoin. Energy Research & Social Science 88 (102499): 1-14.  

Juliet M. Moringiello & Christopher K. Odinet. 2022. The property law of tokens. Florida Law Review 74: 608-671.  

Logan Kugler. 2021. Non-Fungible Tokens and the future of art. Communications of The ACM 64(9): 19-20. 

  1. Labib Fahmi Arif, H. Hendri Tanjung & Hj. Qurroh Ayuniyyah. 2023. Wakaf aset digital: Non-Fungible Token (NFT). Al-Kharaj: Jurnal Ekonomi, Keuangan & Bisnis Syariah 5(4): 1766-1787. 

Matthieu Nadini, Laura Alessandretti, Flavio Di Giacinto, Mauro Martino, Luca Maria Aiello & Andrea Baronchelli. 2021. Mapping the NFT revolution: market trends, trade networks and visual features. Scientific Reports 11(20902).  

Mayukh Mukhopadhyay & Kaushik Ghosh. 2021. Market microstructure of Non-Fungible Tokens. Five Shades of Emerging Business Cases 3: 26-38. 

Mochammad Tanzil Multazam. 2022. Exploring the legal and policy implications of Non-Fungible Tokens. Jurnal Politik dan Pemerintahan Daerah 4(2): 293-303. 

Mohammad Madine, Khaled Salah, Raja Jayaraman & Jamal Zemerly. 2023. NFTs for open-source and commercial software licensing and royalties. IEEE Access 11: 8734-8746.  

Mumtaza Wafda Imala. 2023. Transaksi jual beli Non-Fungible Token (NFT) perspektif fatwa DSN MUI nomor 110 tahun 2017 dan akad jual beli. Tesis Sarjana, Program Studi Hukum Ekonomi Syariah (Muamalah), Universitas Islam Negeri (UIN) Raden Mas Said Surakarta. 

Nafis Alam.  2021. Fintech and the future of finance- rise of NFTs and BNPL.  Malaysia Digital Economy Corporation (MDEC), 28 September. https://blog. mdec. my/ ?p=1263 [6 Julai 2023]. 

Nur Rizqi Febriandika, Fadli & Denizar Abdurrahman Mi’raj. 2022. How are NFT (Non-Fungible Token) transactions reviewed according to Islamic law? Borobudur Law Review 4(1): 1-12.  

Perbadanan Ekonomi Digital Malaysia (MDEC). 2020. MDEC Islamic Fintech Report: 1-19.  

Shofa Robbani & Ifa Khoiria Ningrum. 2022. Non-Fungible Token sebagai aset digital dalam pandangan fiqh muamalah. At-Tuhfah: Jurnal Studi Keislaman 11(2): 1-23.  

Siti Saroh, Listian Indriyani Achmad, Muhammad Hamdan Ainulyaqin & Sarwo Edy. 2023. Analisis transaksi digital Non-Fungible Token (NFT) sebagai instrumen investasi menurut perspektif ekonomi Islam. Jurnal Ilmiah Ekonomi Islam 9(01): 378-386.  

Soualhi, Y. 2023. Shariah Issues – Smart Contract, DeFI & NFT. Slaid. Muzakarah Cendekiawan Syariah Nusantara ke-17. https://muzakarah.inceif.edu.my/kertas-kerja/ 

Sundari, Siti Nur Faiza & Lailatul Rahma. 2022. Business analysis of selling and buying Non-Fungible Tokens (NFT) at marketplace OpenSea according to the perspective of Islamic law. El-Qist: Journal Economics and Business (JIEB) 12: 1-16.  

Xeril Ghaisani Preshila & Asep Ramdan Hidayat. 2022. Analisis fikih muamalah pada praktik transaksi Non-Fungible Token (NFT) di OpenSea. Jurnal Riset Perbankan Syariah (JRPS) 1(2): 77-84. 

Yavuz Toraman & Barış Batuhan Gecit. 2023. User acceptance of Metaverse: an analysis for e-commerce in the framework of Technology Acceptance Model (TAM). Sosyoekonomi 31(55): 85-104.