Sains
Malaysiana 41(3)(2012): 361–366
Group Decision via Usage of Analytic
Hierarchy Process and Preference
Aggregation Method
(Keputusan Berkumpulan Menggunakan
Proses Hierarki Analisis
dan Kaedah Pengagregatan Keutamaan)
Langroudi Majid Zerafat Angiz, Adli Mustafa*,
Noraida Abdul Ghani & Anton Abdulbasah Kamil
Institut Sains Matematik, Fakulti Sains,
Universiti Malaya, 50603 Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia
Diserahkan: 18 Mei 2011 / Diterima: 19
September 2011
ABSTRACT
The Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) is a recognised
modern approach to solve decision making problems. Initially introduced by
Saaty in 1971 as a tool for handling individual decision making situation, the
method has since been extended to incorporate groups. In this paper, a new
method for AHP group decision making is proposed. The method integrates AHP
with a Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA)-based preferential aggregation method.
It manipulates the preferential weights and ranking aspect of each decision
maker in coming up with an optimisation model that determines the best
efficiency score of each alternatives. These efficiency scores are then used to
rank the alternatives and determine the group decision weights. A comparative
analysis of the method with another AHP group decision making method indicates
a similar ‘satisfactory index’ level.
Keywords: Analytic hierarchy process; data
envelopment analysis; group decision making; preference aggregation
ABSTRAK
Proses Hierarki Analisis (PHA) adalah kaedah moden
yang digunakan untuk penyelesaian masalah pembuatan keputusan. Ia diperkenalkan
oleh Saaty pada tahun 1971 sebagai alat untuk mengendali situasi membuat
keputusan individu. Kaedah itu telahpun dikembangkan untuk mengendalikan
situasi membuat keputusan berkumpulan. Dalam kertas ini, satu kaedah baru
pembuatan keputusan berkumpulan PHA dicadangkan. Kaedah ini menggabungkan PHA
dengan kaedah pengagregatan keutamaan yang berasaskan kepada Analisis
Penyampulan Data (APD). Ia menggunakan pemberat keutamaan dan aspek taraf
kedudukan setiap pembuat keputusan dalam menghasilkan suatu model pengoptimuman
untuk menentukan skor kecekapan terbaik setiap alternatif. Skor kecekapan ini
kemudiannya digunakan untuk menaraf kedudukan setiap alternatif dan menentukan
pemberat keputusan kumpulan. Satu analisis perbandingan di antara kaedah yang
dicadangkan dengan satu kaedah pembuatan keputusan berkumpulan PHA yang lain
menghasilkan tahap ’indeks kepuasan’ yang setara.
Kata kunci: Analisis penyampulan data; membuat
keputusan berkumpulan; pengagregatan keutamaan; proses hierarki Analisis
RUJUKAN
Bannerjee, A. 1986. A joint economic lot
size model for purchaser and vendor. Decision Sciences 17: 292-311.
Braglia, M. & Zavanella, L. 2003.
Modelling an industrial strategy for inventory management in supply chains: the
‘Consignment Stock’ case. International Journal of Production
Research 41(16): 3793-3808.
Goyal, S.K. 1977. Determination of
optimal production quantity for a two stage production system. Operational
Research Quarterly 28: 865-870.
Goyal, S.K. 1988. A joint
economic-lot-size model for purchase and vendor : A Comment. Decision
Sciences 19(1): 236.
Goyal, S.K. 1995. Short Communication; A
one-vendor multibuyer integrated inventory model : A comment. European
Journal of Operational Research 82: 209-210. Hill,
R.M. 1999. The optimal production and shipment policy for the single-vendor
single buyer integrated production inventory problem. International Journal
of Production Research 37(11): 2463-2475.
Hill, R.M. & Omar, M. 2006. Another
look at the single-vendor single-buyer integrated production-inventory problem. International Journal of Production Research 44(4): 79-800.
Lu, L. 1995. Theory and Methodology; A
one-vendor multi-buyer integrated inventory model. European Journal of
Operational Research 81: 312-323.
Omar, M. 2009. An integrated equal-lots
policy for shipping a vendor’s final production batch to a single buyer under linearly
decreasing demand. Internation Journal of Production Economics 118:
185-188.
Valentinia, G. & Zavanella, L. 2003.
The consignment stock of inventories: industrial case and performance analysis. International Journal of Production Economics 81-82: 215-224.
*Pengarang
untuk surat-menyurat; email: suzlin@um.edu.my
|